I Purchased 15 Pints to Discover the Finest Cookie Dough Ice Cream

In our quest to seek out one of the best cookie dough ice cream, we scoured the freezer part of a number of grocery shops to select up each model we may discover. As soon as our freezer was stocked to the brim, it was time to begin scooping.

Through the style check, we thought-about a number of components. First was the standard of the ice cream itself. We needed it to style as shut as doable to the stuff you’d discover at finest ice cream outlets! And, after all, we needed each scoop to have loads of cookie dough. Lastly, we thought of worth. Some had been budget-friendly and large enough to serve a crowd for a low value. Others had been dearer, and we had to ensure each spoonful was well worth the funding.

Right here’s each tub we examined:

• Ben & Jerry’s
• Blue Bunny
• Blue Ribbon
• Favourite Day
• Meals Membership
• Nice Worth
• Graeter’s
• Häagen-Dazs
• Halo High
• Jeni’s
• Kemp’s
• Nestle
• Oberweis
• Tillamook
• Turkey Hill

1
/
15

15. Blue Ribbon Classics Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

The very first thing we observed about Blue Ribbon’s 48-ounce tub of cookie dough ice cream was the truth that it wasn’t even known as ice cream. As a substitute, it was known as a frozen dairy dessert. This made us pause to test the ingredient record, and it was very telling. The primary ingredient was really buttermilk, fairly than cream, and we additionally observed high-fructose corn syrup and different components.

The primary spoonful was unappealing. As well as, the cookie dough was sparse and uninteresting. The big tub offered for a really affordable $2.50, making this dessert mild on the pockets.

2
/
15

14. Meals Membership Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Flavored Gentle Ice Cream

This 48-ounce tub from Meals Membership is described as cookie dough-flavored mild ice cream swirled with cookie dough morsels and chocolate flavored chips. The label states that it has 54% much less fats and 23% fewer energy than common ice cream. Components included milk fats and nonfat milk, sugar, lots of components, and synthetic taste.

We discovered it tough to name this cookie dough ice cream. The fluffy and unsubstantial ice cream was sparsely flecked with tiny bits of cookie dough and some chocolate items. We needed to dig across the tub to seek out sufficient to pattern. At $2.89, the ice cream was not an enormous funding, but it surely additionally didn’t have a lot of a payoff.

3
/
15

13. Nice Worth Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Ice Cream

Nice Worth is the home model at Walmart, and the model’s 16-ounce container was definitely a worth at solely $1.87. The primary few components had been additionally promising: milk, cream, skim milk and sugar. Just like the Blue Ribbon model’s product, buttermilk is included into the Nice Worth ice cream. Sadly, the label additionally indicated that this product comprises bioengineered components. The flavour was common, and the cookie dough chunks weren’t vital. All that to say it wasn’t our favourite.

4
/
15

12. Blue Bunny Tremendous Chunky Cookie Dough

Blue Bunny sells a 46-ounce container of “frozen dairy dessert” fairly than actual ice cream. The label describes the product as a cookie dough frozen dairy dessert with cookie dough batter and cookie dough and chocolate flavored chunks. That description alone advised us we shouldn’t count on actual ice cream and that the chunks inside weren’t even actual chocolate, however fairly chocolate flavored bits. We solely need one of the best chocolate chips dotting our ice cream!

The scoops from this tub had been mild and fluffy, with a ribbon of cookie dough batter in addition to items of cookie dough. This was definitely an attention-grabbing twist that we didn’t see in another of the choices we sampled. It may have been fairly scrumptious had the components been of upper high quality. Alas, this $3.99 container wasn’t well worth the barely increased value level.

5
/
15

11. Kemp’s Pillsbury Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Ice Cream

The smiling face of the Pillsbury Doughboy caught our eye after we picked up a 1-1/2-quart tub of Kemp’s ice cream. For those who’re a fan of the Pillsbury refrigerated chocolate chip cookie dough, this ice cream is for you. We may undoubtedly style that signature Pillsbury taste on this product, we simply wished there was extra! Fudge chunks all through made a surprisingly enjoyable addition. At $4.39, this was dearer than a few of the different merchandise, but it surely matched the standard.

6
/
15

10. Turkey Hill Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Ice Cream

The model of this product from Turkey Hill was a bit totally different from all the opposite ones we sampled. Once we took the lid off this 1.44-quart container, we noticed so many small slivers of chocolate that it nearly seemed like cookies and cream. Turkey Hill additionally boasts ice cream that’s cookie dough flavored in addition to having cookie dough chunks. Whereas this sounded good in principle, we couldn’t actually distinguish the flavour base of this ice cream from a traditional vanilla ice cream.

As with others on this rating, there weren’t almost sufficient cookie dough chunks. At $3.69, this ice cream was a great worth, and we preferred the distinctive twists, we simply needed all the pieces to be a bit of extra substantial.

7
/
15

9. Halo High Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Gentle Ice Cream

Halo High is a light-weight ice cream model that tells you upfront what number of energy are in all the pint. For $3.99 and 490 energy per pint, this mild ice cream states that, in comparison with main ice lotions, it has 74% much less fats and 51% fewer energy. We had been additionally intrigued as a result of the label claimed that there could be “mix-ins in each chunk” which is strictly what we had been searching for in a cookie dough ice cream.

We fairly preferred the distinctive caramelized taste of the ice cream itself, however discovered there weren’t precisely bits of cookie dough in each chunk. That being stated, this was our favourite of the sunshine ice cream choices.

8
/
15

8. Nestle Toll Home Cookie Dough Ice Cream

This product caught our eye, as a result of if anybody is aware of the perfect recipe for cookie dough, it’s the parents at Nestle Toll Home. That additionally means we went in with excessive expectations for the standard of the chocolate chips in addition to the cookie dough.

We liked the extra mini Nestle Toll Home morsels scattered all through the ice cream, however wished there have been much more. While you’re acknowledged with having a few of the finest cookie dough, there’s no cause to carry again. Having made the long-lasting chocolate chip cookie recipe many occasions, we may undoubtedly style the flavour of that traditional recipe within the bites of cookie dough, which was improbable. At $4.39, this product was barely dearer than different choices, however we really feel the standard was value it.

9
/
15

7. Tillamook Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Ice Cream

The ice cream from Tillamook was definitely distinctive amongst all those we tried. The carton states, “Tillamook ice cream is made with extra cream than is legally required. Our ice cream is easy, wealthy and additional creamy.” From the primary scoop, we discovered this to be completely true. The ice cream was mild and ethereal whereas additionally being extraordinarily creamy.

It was tremendous simple to scoop, and it was made with actual components and fewer components than different merchandise. However the cookie dough bits had been undoubtedly hiding on this carton. In truth, we needed to actually dig simply to seek out some. For $5.99, this was a extra premium price ticket for a better high quality product. For those who like your ice cream very, very creamy, this one from Tillamook is for you.

10
/
15

6. Favourite Day Cookie Dough Ice Cream

Favourite Day is without doubt one of the home manufacturers at Goal, and its cookie dough ice cream was a standout compared to different budget-friendly generic choices. The 1-1/2-quart container is a improbable worth at $3.49.

With out making the leap into the far more costly, super-premium ice cream market, this was our favourite. The flavour of the ice cream was on level and there have been vital items of decadent cookie dough in each chunk. As a bonus, there was a recipe for cookie dough ice cream bars proper on the bundle. We’ll you should definitely try different varieties from Favourite Day, and this ice cream will probably find yourself in our Goal carts on the common from right here on out.

11
/
15

5. Jeni’s Ice Cream Double Dough

It’s no shock that the highest-ranked ice lotions on our record would possibly include a better price ticket. That’s partially as a result of they’re made with premium high quality components. The $8.49 pint from Jeni’s ice cream isn’t any exception. The model’s excellent merchandise are made with grass-grazed dairy merchandise, and the distinction is important.

Along with the items of cookie dough within the Jeni’s pint, the ice cream itself is designed to style precisely like wealthy and buttery cookie dough. The model tried to imitate the expertise of having fun with fluffy dough made with creamed butter and brown sugar and evenly kissed with vanilla. It’s described as an ultra-creamy brown sugar custard with caramelized depth. There is no such thing as a doubt that is an unimaginable product.

Our solely qualm is that calling it “double dough” is barely deceptive. We tasted extra of the caramelized facet of the ice cream greater than we did the cookie dough. For those who’re searching for essentially the most distinctive and richly flavored ice cream on our record, that is the way in which to go.

12
/
15

4. Häagen-Dazs Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Ice Cream

The title Häagen-Dazs has been synonymous with wonderful ice cream for years. This 14-ounce container of chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream retails for $4.39, which is considerably lower than different premium merchandise in the marketplace.

We liked trying on the ingredient record and truly with the ability to pronounce all the pieces on the carton. Cream, milk, sugar—simply the great things right here. The signature vanilla ice cream was simply as delectable as we remembered, and the bits of soppy and buttery cookie dough had been plentiful. There have been additionally chocolate chips combined all through. It’s described as a “cookie dough lover’s dream come true,” and we couldn’t agree extra.

13
/
15

3. Oberweis Tremendous Premium Cookie Dough Ice Cream

If you need essentially the most bang in your buck, decide up a pint of Oberweis for $4.69. Since 1927, Oberweis has been making high-quality ice cream, and it exhibits no indicators of stopping. Out of all of the merchandise we sampled, this was one of the best of one of the best when it got here to the ice cream base. After all, the cookie dough was top-notch as nicely.

We liked the little bit of poetry on the again of the carton. It says, “Our cookie dough ice cream awakens childhood reminiscences, as you savor candy spoonfuls of delectable dough, drenched in our vanilla ice cream, taking you again to that indulgent second whenever you final licked the spoon clear.” That completely summarizes our expertise consuming this ice cream. It was so good, it made it exhausting to rank these high three with out giving all of them the primary spot.

14
/
15

2. Ben and Jerry’s Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

Ben and Jerry’s claims to have originated the idea of cookie dough ice cream. The model says, “We knew we had been on to one thing large after we made the world’s first batch of chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream in 1984. In the present day the flavour nonetheless reigns amongst our all-time hottest concoctions.” We discovered that this pint from Ben and Jerry’s contained far and away one of the best cookie dough of the lot. The balls of excellent dough had been enormous and included into each chunk. There was no must dig round for the yummy bits, as a result of the cookie dough was entrance and middle. If an important think about a scoop of cookie dough ice cream is the dough itself, look no additional; Ben and Jerry’s is the way in which to go. Plus, at $4.49 per pint, the worth was acceptable for the standard.