The High Copycat Samoas, In accordance with a Professional Baker

Searching for the right copycat Samoas? Lady Scout Cookie season solely occurs every year, however we discovered year-round dupes that stack up fairly properly in opposition to the originals.

Our editors and consultants handpick each product we characteristic. We might earn a fee out of your purchases.

1
/
6

MOLLY ALLEN FOR TASTE OF HOME

How We Examined Copycat Samoas

To seek out the perfect Samoa cookies, we bought a field of authentic Samoa Lady Scout Cookies together with 4 copycat variations. (We did the same check with the best grocery store cakes.)

The purpose of this style check was to search out one thing higher or equal to the beloved Samoas that Lady Scouts promote. That meant discovering a ring-shaped deal with with a pleasant crisp cookie (sometimes shortbread), a beneficiant quantity of gooey caramel, flaked coconut and a contact of chocolate to spherical all of it out.

2
/
6

Molly Allen for Style of Residence

Safeway Signature Choose Caramel Coconut Fudge Cookies

This feature may be discovered at Safeway shops or many Albertsons shops. It seemed fairly an identical to each the Benton’s cookies and the Crav’n cookies however didn’t style or really feel the identical. Whereas the flavour was first rate, this caramel coconut fudge deal with lacked stability. It had a really thick shortbread cookie within the middle with out sufficient caramel or fudge to stability it out.

Backside line: Whereas not dangerous, the ratio of cookie to caramel to fudge wasn’t sufficient to make this Samoa copycat stand out from the remainder.

3
/
6

Molly Allen for Style of Residence

Keebler Coconut Desires

We have been stunned this selection from Keebler didn’t rank larger. It did have a superb quantity of fudge, each on the underside and the highest, however extra isn’t essentially higher when it brings extra sweetness to the combination. There was much less chocolate taste and fewer caramel. It had a dry, crunchy cookie within the middle, too—under no circumstances like an actual Samoa.

Backside line: General, Keebler Coconut Desires have been OK. The great stability of chocolate, caramel and cookie simply wasn’t there.

4
/
6

Molly Allen for Style of Residence

Crav’n Caramel Coconut Fudgy Striped Cookies

Crav’n Caramel Coconut Fudgy Striped Cookies may be discovered at plenty of retailers, together with Walmart. The cookies had a chewier shortbread middle that wasn’t fairly as thick, however there wasn’t a lot caramel. Whereas this model does rank larger on the record for good taste, there have been just a few textural qualities we discovered missing when in comparison with the Lady Scout model.

Backside line: It is a first rate various in case you’re craving Samoas within the lifeless of fall and may’t wait till the subsequent spherical of Lady Scout Cookies go on sale.

5
/
6

Molly Allen for Style of Residence

Benton’s Caramel Coconut Fudge Cookies

These Caramel Coconut Fudge cookies may be discovered at Aldi shops. In comparison with others, there’s undoubtedly extra shortbread as the bottom of the cookie. A skinny layer of caramel tops the cookie, and the bottom is dipped in fudge. Although it’s not as a lot fudge as we anticipated, the packaging does word that the cookies are made with actual cocoa. Although a bit sweeter, the general taste of those Aldi copycat cookies was good.

Backside line: We hoped for a bit extra chewiness from the caramel, however general, the flavour was good. It is a first rate dupe and we love that Aldi copycat Lady Scout Cookies can be found all yr!