All merchandise featured on Bon Appétit are independently chosen by our editors. Nonetheless, we could obtain compensation from retailers and/or from purchases of merchandise via these hyperlinks.
For those who’re questioning whether or not you want a boning knife, I’ve one query for you: Do you eat meat, poultry, and fish? If the reply is sure, likelihood is having one in all these will make your life a complete lot simpler—and may even prevent some cash whereas affording you extra flexibility together with your cooking, since you’ll be capable to purchase massive proteins and break them down your self.
The perfect boning knives
- Greatest boning knife general: Wüsthof Basic Boning Knife
- Greatest finances boning knife: Victorinox Fibrox Boning Knife
- A boning knife improve: Shun Premier Boning Knife
In contrast to a chef’s knife, paring knife, or bread knife, a boning knife gained’t are available most kitchen knife units, neither is it one thing you’ll essentially use day by day. However for duties like slicing fish into fillets, trimming fats off a brisket, breaking down a rooster, or eradicating that pesky layer of silverskin from a lower of meat, there’s no higher software for the job. That’s as a result of the most effective boning knives have sharp ideas and skinny, versatile blades that make them uniquely nimble and wieldy.
Now that we’ve (hopefully) offered you on why a boning knife is a worthy addition to your knife assortment, learn on to study the easiest ones.
The perfect boning knife general: Wüsthof Basic Boning Knife
Wüsthof Basic 5.5″ Boning Knife
Professionals
- Consumer-friendly straight blade
- Snug to carry
- Straightforward to sharpen
Cons
- Might not be the most effective decide for extra skilled cooks
For a superb boning knife that may serve each skilled cooks and beginner house cooks properly, our high decide is the Wüsthof Basic.
The Wüsthof Basic’s straight blade makes it extra user-friendly as a result of in contrast to a curved boning knife (extra on the variations down right here), it offers customers a transparent line of sight between their hand and the tip of the knife as they work. This makes it simpler to make exact cuts, regardless of your talent degree.
Apart from blade form there was much more to like in regards to the Wüsthof Basic. The contoured polypropylene deal with and beneficiant bolster make it snug to carry in a wide range of grips. The stability between the load of the blade and that of the deal with felt good, and the knife was light-weight whereas nonetheless providing sufficient heft to deal with the butchering duties at hand. The blade itself is skinny with out feeling flimsy. It strikes the correct stability relating to flexibility, capable of navigate round muscle and tissue with spectacular agility with out sacrificing the rigidity wanted to chop via the denser elements of a lower of meat.
Whereas it’s essential to maintain your entire knives in razor sharp situation, that is very true for boning knives—which is why we had been happy with how properly the Wüsthof retained its sharp edge in testing, and the way straightforward it was to keep up at house with a knife sharpener when the time got here because of its blade’s heavy, straight-sided metal.
The Wüsthof Basic was the most effective all-arounder we examined, however a extra skilled cook dinner may take into account choosing a knife with a curved blade (nice for navigating round massive bones) or a thinner, extra versatile blade (higher for fileting fish). However in case you’re in search of a boning knife that may accommodate all talent ranges, it is a good spot to start out.
Blade type: Straight
Blade size: 5”
Blade materials: Stainless-steel
Deal with materials: Polypropylene
The perfect finances boning knife: Victorinox Fibrox Boning Knife
Victorinox Swiss Military Fibrox Curved Boning Knife
Professionals
- Good stability of flexibility vs. rigidity
- Nice worth level
Cons
- Curved blade is much less beginner-friendly and more durable to sharpen
For those who’re new to boning knives and are usually not eager on spending upwards of $100 on one, go for the Victorinox Fibrox. Victorinox’s line of budget-friendly knives are inclined to fare properly throughout our product exams, and this $30 knife isn’t any exception.
In testing, we discovered the Victorinox boning knife straightforward to manage and comfy to carry because of its textured ergonomic deal with. Just like the Wüsthof, the blade strikes a Goldilocks excellent when it comes to flexibility versus rigidity, equally adept at skinning fish as it’s slicing cleanly via a thick slab of meat. And whereas the mannequin we examined includes a curved blade, the slope was light sufficient that we had been nonetheless capable of execute exact cuts with ease.
If the Victorinox’s worth level appeals to you however you’re in search of a barely totally different kind of blade, concern not! The model gives a number of variations of this mannequin, together with one with a extra versatile blade, and a straight-sided possibility. All ring in at across the identical worth.
Whereas the curve of this mannequin’s blade is slight, it nonetheless could take novices a while to discover ways to correctly work with it. That curve additionally means this knife isn’t fairly as straightforward to sharpen as a straight-sided knife just like the Wüsthof.
Blade type: Curved
Blade size: 6”
Blade materials: Stainless-steel
Deal with materials: Thermoplastic rubber
A boning knife improve: Shun Premier Boning Knife
Shun Premier Boning Knife, 6″
Professionals
- Luxe feel and look
- Snug to carry
- Inflexible blade offers stability
Cons
- Costly
- Curved blade makes it much less beginner-friendly
For those who’re a extra skilled cook dinner who’s no stranger to butchering meat, we’d level you to the Shun Premier.
Apart from a luxe look (with a luxe price ticket to match), The Shun Premier has a curved blade that’s much less newbie pleasant, however affords you higher visibility when doing horizontal cuts like fileting fish or butterflying a rooster breast into skinny cutlets. The blade’s rigidity can be one thing to notice—it offers stability for individuals who know methods to correctly wield it.
In testing, this knife really felt like an extension of the hand. The pakkawood deal with is designed to be snug to carry in each a set off and pinch grip relying in your desire. We additionally love the look of the shiny hammered end of the stainless-steel, inside which lies a high-carbon VG-MAX “super-steel” core.
That is undeniably an costly knife, and it’s not the most suitable choice for everybody. Most of the attributes that make it so nice for knowledgeable house cooks additionally make it tough to get the cling of for novices—specifically, the curve and rigidity of the blade.
Blade type: Curved
Blade size: 6”
Blade materials: Damascus metal
Deal with materials: Pakkawood
How we examined boning knives
To check boning knives we used them every to interrupt down a complete rooster—a activity that requires a wide range of forms of actions and cuts and is thus notably telling of a knife’s benefit. We eliminated the white and darkish meat sections from the carcass, then used the tip of the knife to separate the wings. We made rooster “lollipops” by slicing the meat of the drumsticks away from the bone, after which got down to debone the thighs.
We evaluated every knife based mostly on the next standards:
The perfect boning knives strike a stability relating to weight. They need to be gentle sufficient that they’re straightforward to maneuver, however hefty sufficient to deal with harder duties like slicing via joints and cartilage.
Is the deal with snug to carry?
An excellent boning knife ought to accommodate each underhand and overhand grips, and make switching between the 2 whereas working as straightforward as doable.
Boning knives come both straight-edged or with curved blades, and each have their advantages. {Many professional} cooks desire curved blades, that are notably adept at breaking down massive cuts of meat. These require some getting used to, although, because the expertise of utilizing one is sort of totally different from that of the straight-edged knives most house cooks are acquainted with. The good thing about a straight blade is that it’s extra user-friendly and acts as an extension of the hand, permitting its consumer to make exact cuts with relative ease.
How thick and lengthy is the blade? Does it retain its edge properly?
Boning knives want a blade that’s skinny however not flimsy, able to cleanly slicing the connective tissue between meat and bone. The blade’s size can be essential. All the knives we examined had blades between 5 and 6 inches in size, which we discovered to be an optimum center floor. We additionally paid consideration to every blade’s edge retention over time. Clearly we anticipated sharp blades out of the field, however appeared for ones that held their edge and sharpened properly after they finally dulled.
Different boning knives we examined
Mercer Culinary Millenia 6″ Boning Knife
Mercer Culinary Millenia 6″ Boning Knife
It is a nice boning knife for the worth. We discovered the textured, ergonomic deal with snug to grip, and it fared properly in our testing. It in the end misplaced out to the Victorinox as a result of its extra aggressive curve makes it much less beginner-friendly—one thing we had been in search of in our decide for an reasonably priced knife. That stated, in case you’re assured in your boning knife abilities and in search of a budget-friendly possibility, the Mercer will serve you properly.
Zwilling Professional 5.5″ Versatile Boning Knife
Zwilling Versatile Boning Knife, 5.5″
We preferred the blade of this knife, however the sharp, angular design of its bolster saved it from incomes our suggestion. It was uncomfortable to grip once we wanted to choke up on the deal with, and made it painful to change between overhand and underhand holds.
Dexter Russell 6″ Boning Knife
Dexter-Russell 6″ Boning Knife
We discovered the deal with of this knife too cumbersome to comfortably maintain and maneuver, which disqualified it from a high spot.
Steelport 6″ Boning Knife
Steelport 6″ Boning Knife
Steelport knives are lovely and this one isn’t any exception. With its carbon metal blade and fairly wooden deal with, we actually wished to love this one—however sadly, it didn’t show to be as purposeful as we’d hoped. The blade was too lengthy for our liking, the deal with was too large to afford us the management we had been in search of, and the knife was general too heavy to be snug to make use of for the duties we introduced it with.
Extra product test-winning knives to finish your assortment
There’s nobody excellent knife, however we’ll enable you to discover the most effective one for you.
A fragile software for delicate duties
Please, please don’t get extra knives than you want.
When you’ve learn up on the entire finest knives, head this option to study honing rods and knife sharpeners
Extra testing and reporting by Allison Robicelli