HomeWorld NewsJudge Rules ICE’s “Third-Country” Deportations Are Unconstitutional

Judge Rules ICE’s “Third-Country” Deportations Are Unconstitutional

Published on

spot_img

A lawyer for migrants in the case called the ruling “a forceful statement” that the White House has ignored the law.

Under surveillance by immigration and customs officers, Salvadorean illegal immigrants fly over Mexican airspace on their way to El Salvador, deported from the United States, on December 18, 2008.

Support justice-driven, accurate and transparent news — make a quick donation to Truthout today! 

A federal judge ruled on Wednesday that a policy used by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) to deport undocumented immigrants living in the U.S. to countries where they are not citizens is an unconstitutional denial of their due process rights.

So-called “Third-Country Removals” were adopted as official ICE policy in a memo last year, allowing for such deportations to take place with as little as six hours’ notice.

U.S. District Judge Brian E. Murphy, who is based in Boston, found that the memo fails to provide sufficient time for migrants to challenge the agency’s actions.

“This new policy — which purports to stand in for the protections Congress has mandated — fails to satisfy due process for a raft of reasons,” Murphy wrote in his order.

The government, in defending the policy, had argued they were providing “assurances” to migrants that they wouldn’t face persecution or harm in the third countries they were being deported to. Murphy rejected that premise, noting, “nobody really knows anything about these purported ‘assurances.’”

“It is not fine, nor is it legal [to send people to an] unfamiliar and potentially dangerous country” without granting them any legal recourse, Murphy stated, adding:

These are our laws, and it is with profound gratitude for the unbelievable luck of being born in the United States of America that this Court affirms these and our nation’s bedrock principle: that no ‘person’ in this country may be ‘deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law.’

Murphy also chastised the Trump administration for disobeying previous temporary orders he had issued, noting that officials had “repeatedly violated, or attempted to violate” his directives.

In a statement to The New York Times, a Justice Department spokesperson alleged that “the district court continues to ignore clear law.” The Trump administration is expected to appeal the ruling, which Murphy anticipated, placing a 15-day hold on his ruling.

Trina Realmuto, executive director of the National Immigration Litigation Alliance, which represented migrants in the case, lauded Murphy’s ruling.

“Under the government’s policy, people have been forcibly returned to countries where U.S. immigration judges have found they will be persecuted or tortured,” Realmuto pointed out, adding that Murphy’s ruling “is a forceful statement from the court that the administration has been violating the law.”

According to the American Immigration Council, prior to the Trump administration, the U.S. rarely conducted third-country deportations — when they did, it was under individual circumstances, not a general policy affecting a broad population of migrants.

“U.S. law requires the government not to deport anyone to a country in which they will be persecuted or tortured, or to deport them to a country that will then send them into harm,” the organization states on its website. “The Trump administration’s use of third-country deportations to send people into foreign prisons indefinitely; the lack of notice or due process afforded to immigrants before being sent to third countries; and several cases in which people ended up in countries where they had formally shown they were likely to be persecuted or tortured, all raise serious questions about the U.S. government’s compliance with its own laws in making and carrying out third-country deportation deals.”

A terrifying moment. We appeal for your support.

In the last weeks, we have witnessed an authoritarian assault on communities in Minnesota and across the nation.

The need for truthful, grassroots reporting is urgent at this cataclysmic historical moment. Yet, Trump-aligned billionaires and other allies have taken over many legacy media outlets — the culmination of a decades-long campaign to place control of the narrative into the hands of the political right.

We refuse to let Trump’s blatant propaganda machine go unchecked. Untethered to corporate ownership or advertisers, Truthout remains fearless in our reporting and our determination to use journalism as a tool for justice.

But we need your help just to fund our basic expenses. Over 80 percent of Truthout’s funding comes from small individual donations from our community of readers, and over a third of our total budget is supported by recurring monthly donors.

Truthout’s fundraiser ends tonight! We have a goal to add 130 new monthly donors before midnight. Whether you can make a small monthly donation or a larger one-time gift, Truthout only works with your support.

Latest articles

Asia markets set to open higher amid renewed Iran-U.S. tensions

Currency dealers monitor exchange rates as an electronic screen (top) shows South Korea's benchmark stock index (KOSPI) in a foreign exchange dealing room at the Hana Bank headquarters in Seoul on March 13, 2026. Jung Yeon-je | Afp | Getty Images Asia-Pacific markets were mixed Monday, as investors continue to keep a cautious eye on

Oil prices jump after Iran and U.S. attack commercial ships as tensions escalate over Strait of Hormuz

A picture taken on March 12, 2017, shows a view of an oil facility in the Khark Island, on the shore of the Gulf. Atta Kenare | Afp | Getty Images Crude oil prices surged Sunday, as the U.S. and Iran teetered on the brink of a renewed war after attacks on commercial ships in

Here are things going right for stocks despite new Iran war setbacks

Subscribe to CNBC PRO Subscribe to Investing Club Licensing & Reprints CNBC Councils Select Personal Finance Join the CNBC Panel Closed Captioning Digital Products News Releases Internships Corrections About CNBC Site Map Podcasts Careers Help Contact News Tips Got a confidential news tip? We want to hear from you.Get In Touch CNBC Newsletters Sign up

U.S. struck, seized Iranian-flagged ship Touska in Gulf of Oman, Trump says

U.S. President Donald Trump speaks to the media, before boarding Air Force One on his way to Virginia, at Joint Base Andrews in Maryland, U.S., April 10, 2026. Evelyn Hockstein | Reuters A U.S Navy guided missile destroyer fired on and disabled an Iranian-flagged cargo ship in the Gulf of Oman before Marines boarded and

More like this

Asia markets set to open higher amid renewed Iran-U.S. tensions

Currency dealers monitor exchange rates as an electronic screen (top) shows South Korea's benchmark stock index (KOSPI) in a foreign exchange dealing room at the Hana Bank headquarters in Seoul on March 13, 2026. Jung Yeon-je | Afp | Getty Images Asia-Pacific markets were mixed Monday, as investors continue to keep a cautious eye on

Oil prices jump after Iran and U.S. attack commercial ships as tensions escalate over Strait of Hormuz

A picture taken on March 12, 2017, shows a view of an oil facility in the Khark Island, on the shore of the Gulf. Atta Kenare | Afp | Getty Images Crude oil prices surged Sunday, as the U.S. and Iran teetered on the brink of a renewed war after attacks on commercial ships in

Here are things going right for stocks despite new Iran war setbacks

Subscribe to CNBC PRO Subscribe to Investing Club Licensing & Reprints CNBC Councils Select Personal Finance Join the CNBC Panel Closed Captioning Digital Products News Releases Internships Corrections About CNBC Site Map Podcasts Careers Help Contact News Tips Got a confidential news tip? We want to hear from you.Get In Touch CNBC Newsletters Sign up