Afrigather Researchers in Australia have in contrast the technical and monetary performances of a hydrogen battery storage system and a lithium-ion battery when coupled with rooftop PV. They evaluated two commercially out there programs – LAVO and Tesla Powerwall 2 – and located that the lithium-ion battery offers higher monetary income, whereas the hydrogen battery affords extra battery lifespan for lengthy length of power storage.
Each hydrogen batteries and lithium-ion batteries have been recognized as promising stationary power storage options for integration with rooftop photo voltaic programs. Nonetheless, whereas lithium-ion batteries have been extensively put in by each properties and companies, hydrogen batteries solely began to take off in 2021 with the world’s first business deployments by Australia-based startup LAVO.
Each applied sciences have their execs and cons. Hydrogen batteries have round 40% decrease roundtrip efficiencies than lithium-ion ones, translating into extra power losses that would influence grid imports and value of electrical energy in assembly power demand. Then again, hydrogen batteries have much less capability degradation and better power density than lithium-ion ones. This enables them to retailer extra power for an extended length, which may have an effect on the self-sufficiency and payback durations of the rooftop photo voltaic programs.
Addressing a data hole on the technical and monetary efficiency of hydrogen batteries, researchers on the University of New South Wales (UNSW) in Australia have modeled the operation of a business hydrogen battery coupled with a rooftop PV system, utilizing Time of Use (ToU) and photo voltaic feed-in tariffs, and in contrast the efficiency with a business lithium-ion battery underneath a photo voltaic and arbitrage scheme.
They evaluated the performances of the 13.5 kWh commercially out there batteries – LAVO and Tesla Powerwall 2 – and an operational 4.5 kW rooftop PV system underneath six totally different situations. Their mannequin thought of battery growing older and efficiency degradation, with outcomes suggesting that each hydrogen and lithium-ion batteries can cut back grid dependency and decrease electrical energy prices by minimizing grid imports.
The researchers discovered that the lithium-ion battery outperforms the hydrogen battery in higher capability utilization because of decrease roundtrip power losses. “The lithium-ion battery generates larger web earnings, attaining a payback interval 9 years earlier within the arbitrage scheme and 1 12 months within the photo voltaic scheme in comparison with the hydrogen battery,” the researchers reported, explaining that, underneath the photo voltaic scheme, the batteries are charged and discharged following the electrical energy demand and availability of the rooftop PV technology.
Standard content material
The hydrogen battery consumed extra power than the lithium-ion battery in arbitrage and underneath the photo voltaic scheme, which resulted in customers paying extra to power retailers to function hydrogen batteries in rooftop photo voltaic PV programs. Moreover, much less earnings was generated underneath the ToU and photo voltaic feed-in tariffs utilizing a hydrogen battery as in comparison with a lithium-ion battery, which contributed towards an extended payback interval for the hydrogen battery.
Nonetheless, the researchers additionally discovered that the hydrogen battery demonstrates an extended lifespan, enduring 18% extra charge-discharge cycles than the lithium-ion battery. “This makes the hydrogen battery appropriate for distant functions requiring prolonged length of power storage,” the researchers mentioned. Nonetheless, with water required to generate hydrogen, hydrogen batteries should not appropriate for areas that have water shortages.
“Subsequently, the selection of optimum battery system for rooftop PV system will depend on the provision of water useful resource, climate extremes and the trade-off between the desire for higher monetary revenue or prolonged battery cycle life,” the researchers say, noting that the photo voltaic scheme is the only option for each varieties of batteries in a residential setting to generate most monetary revenue.
Their outcomes have been mentioned within the paper “Assessment of hydrogen and lithium-ion batteries in rooftop solar PV systems,” revealed within the Journal of Vitality Storage.
This content material is protected by copyright and might not be reused. If you wish to cooperate with us and want to reuse a few of our content material, please contact: editors@pv-magazine.com.
