As the saying goes, “Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery,” but when celebs opt for similar Halloween costumes, we gotta ask y’all: Who’d You Rather?!

“It’s Britney B*tch!” Paris Hilton rocked a schoolgirl outfit from the “Hit Me Baby One More Time” era, while Casey Boonstra sported a “I’m A Slave For You” ‘fit … Which iconic Britney look is best?!

“Edward Scissor Hands?! More like “Edward SZA Hands!” Musicians Lizzo and Saweetie nailed the spooky classic … But there can only be one winner!

Avanai Gregg is known for her intricate makeup work, and of course, James Charles is a makeup guru, but which Avatar is giving you the blues and who’s comin’ out on top?!

Y’all know the drill … Hit up the gallery, cast your faves and vote Who’d You Rather?!