England had been crushed 2-1 by Greece of their first aggressive Wembley defeat for 4…

After Lee Carsley suffered the primary blip in his audition for the England supervisor’s job – if he desires the function, that’s – Sky Sports activities’ soccer writers have a look at what went mistaken within the 2-1 residence loss to Greece.

Too many stars, not sufficient stability

Lee Carsley ought to have discovered from the errors of those who had come earlier than him. You merely can’t cram a bunch of stars into one crew and hope for one of the best.

There was pleasure that the person auditioning to interchange Gareth Southgate was stepping away from the cautious method of the final regime, however England went all out assault and had two photographs heading in the right direction in opposition to Greece, the forty eighth greatest nation on the planet, at residence.

• England 1-2 Greece – report & evaluation
• How the groups lined up | Match stats
• Nations League tables | Fixtures
• Stream Sky Sports activities with NOW

Though Southgate was extra measured, he additionally fell into the identical entice. He selected star names over stability on the Euros, maybe to handle egos, and it backfired. England reached the ultimate however by no means appeared like a crew deserving of leaving with the trophy.

It was naive of Carsley to assume Cole Palmer, Jude Bellingham, Phil Foden, Bukayo Saka and Anthony Gordon in a single beginning XI can be a sustainable line-up, particularly with – in Carsley’s phrases – solely 20 minutes of coaching time within the system the day earlier than the sport. Even when England had coasted previous Greece, what objective would it not serve for a serious event?

England want a supervisor robust sufficient to drop the celebrities, somebody with the gravitas to take care of the fallout after they make the massive selections, and Carsley doesn’t appear to suit the invoice.

The unattainable job has confirmed too huge for coaches way more skilled than England’s interim. Whoever lastly finds success should be extra ruthless with the celebrities.
Zinny Boswell

Why overlook Watkins & Solanke regardless of Kane being unfit?

England’s interim head coach Lee Carsley opted to begin Thursday evening’s Nations League conflict in opposition to Greece with 5 attackers on the pitch, however no precise out-and-out striker within the absence of the injured Harry Kane, with each in-form frontmen Ollie Watkins and Dominic Solanke left to observe proceedings from the substitutes’ bench.

Nevertheless, that system clearly did not get one of the best out of the aspect in possession with England having simply two photographs heading in the right direction – within the third minute and their 87th-minute purpose – each from Bellingham, whereas additionally leaving them susceptible to the counter-attack with out it because the guests recorded their first win at Wembley Stadium.

On the method to fill the beginning line-up with attacking expertise, however with out a centre ahead, Carsley – who then launched Watkins on the hour mark, with Solanke following 12 minutes later because the hosts switched to 4-4-2 – defined after the loss: “I believe it is a case of making an attempt one thing completely different.

“The expectation is that we simply decide a crew that beat Greece comfortably at Wembley. You have to consider the opposition are extremely motivated and attempt to cease you.”

Carsley is hopeful of getting his captain again to guide the road in opposition to Finland in Helsinki on Sunday, though regardless of how unbalanced the crew appeared in opposition to Greece, the 50-year-old nonetheless refused to rule out adopting an identical attacking line-up in future video games.

“I do not assume [this approach is] one thing that it is best to rule out. At occasions we’ve to be artistic, particularly with the gamers that we have got, however there was clearly quite a lot of challenges tonight.”
Richard Morgan

Foden produces one other England dud show

“Cannot begin a hearth with out a spark” was the mantra England followers gave Phil Foden at Euro 2024. That spark has not flickered for some time.

One other clean for Foden means it’s now 15 straight Three Lions matches with out a purpose or an help. His final worldwide purpose contribution got here 12 months in the past.

Foden will level in the direction of not having a settled spot on this England crew, with final time period’s Premier League Participant of the Season usually shoehorned on the left, notably at Euro 2024.

However the Greece sport was an opportunity for Foden to indicate his price in a free central function and he ended the sport with zero possibilities created, zero photographs and nil take-ons accomplished.

When are we going to see the actual Phil Foden for England?
Sam Blitz

Is Alexander-Arnold England’s most suitable choice at right-back?

Trent Alexander-Arnold made his first successive begin for England for the primary time in his profession in Thursday evening’s defeat to Greece.

Beneath Carsley, it is a image of the rising significance and probably cracking the code as to how one can get one of the best out of one in all England’s best gamers.

Nevertheless, regardless of creating essentially the most probabilities of any participant on the pitch, Alexander-Arnold’s defensive play has been drawn into query as soon as once more. His lax show on the again meant that point after time, Greece discovered pleasure on that left aspect of the pitch.

It begs the query as as to if Kyle Walker stays England’s most suitable choice at right-back. Reintroduced into the squad for this spherical of internationals, Walker was an unused substitute in opposition to Greece.

The Manchester Metropolis right-back has fallen down the pecking order after his underwhelming shows at Euro 2024 in the summertime however maybe stays the tried, examined and trusted right-back.

Carsley appears intent on bringing the common age of his England aspect down and at 34 years outdated, Walker most likely represents the outdated guard inside the Three Lions squad, current for his expertise reasonably than what he can carry to the aspect.

Nevertheless, with Alexander-Arnold but to convincingly pin down the place, Walker might discover himself again within the aspect.
William Bitibiri

Is Guehi’s omission too harsh after Euro 2024 heroics?

England appeared defensively suspect and their greatest defender from Euro 2024 was sat on the bench.

Marc Guehi has not acknowledged the season brilliantly with Crystal Palace however the credit score he constructed up because the Three Lions’ most dependable possibility on the again in Germany final summer time appears to have disappeared.

Carsley went for John Stones – captain for the evening – and Levi Colwill on the again, the primary time the pair had performed collectively within the centre of defence for England. With a lot uncertainty on the prime finish of the pitch, certainly some solidity and recognisable faces on the again would have helped with the experiment.

Stones and Colwill had been fantastic on the again – the latter particularly has began the season properly for Chelsea and there are far more points on this England crew that the centre-back pairing.

However when England had been wanting unconvincing at Euro 2024, Guehi bailed out England’s backline to ensure they stored going by way of the rounds and choosing up wins. The Palace defender’s fall from grace appears odd.
Sam Blitz

If not Carsley, then who?

England had a reasonably substantial and equally enticing checklist of potential replacements when Southgate introduced his resignation in mid-July. Eddie Howe, for thus lengthy seen because the FA’s protege, Graham Potter and Mauricio Pochettino with Carsley as a reliable fall-back possibility given his achievements with the U21s.

Now, Pochettino is unavailable and Carsley’s hopes of getting the job have taken a sudden hit. Howe gave his very conditional loyalty to Newcastle which was examined by a poor switch window and the departure of Amanda Staveley, who was instrumental in bringing him to the membership.

Nevertheless, he has a long-term contract on Tyneside and there have at all times been query marks about whether or not the FA may afford to purchase him out of it.

Pep Guardiola has at all times been a pipe dream and can be accessible at no cost subsequent summer time, however this implies a minimum of one other seven video games with out a everlasting supervisor and although he has at all times spoken positively in regards to the job, there is no such thing as a assure he’s prepared to surrender on membership soccer – or Man Metropolis – simply but.

Thomas Tuchel has been talked about extra lately however England have by no means felt snug with international managers in cost, least of all one bearing the flag of their greatest rivals. And, with rising hypothesis Manchester United might flip to him in the event that they eliminate Erik ten Hag, he might not be accessible for for much longer anyway.

That leaves Potter, who would by no means show the sort of tactical naivety we noticed at Wembley on Thursday, however who shortly confirmed in his one elite-level job at Chelsea he might not have the power to take care of the sort of personalities who occupy the dressing room.

Particularly when quite a lot of these are both within the present England squad, or have been referred to as up lately.

Mark Bullingham is giving the impression of a person keen to bide his time earlier than selecting Southgate’s alternative, having held off from contacting any of Howe, Potter or Tuchel. In the intervening time that also appears to be like the wisest alternative.

As a result of, within the absence of a stand-out candidate, England can afford failed experiments like Carsley’s in opposition to Greece with a Pot 1 World Cup 2026 qualifying spot virtually sure, leaving them with out a main worldwide obligation arising till the finals of that event in virtually two years’ time.
Ron Walker