COP29 Bulletin Day 5: Stress to scrub up COPs and shortfall in adaptation pledges

This text shall be up to date all through the day and an edited model shall be despatched out every night as a publication – you’ll be able to join right here.

Is the tip close to for COPs in petrostates?

Fossil fuels have loved heat hospitality at COPs lately, with the final two local weather summits being held in fossil fuel-expanding petrostates and COP presidencies even getting caught selling oil and fuel offers on the job.

That’s why a bunch of prime local weather specialists, scientists and former UN chiefs referred to as for reform in an open letter revealed this Friday, the place they argue that nations increasing oil and fuel shouldn’t be in a position to maintain the COP presidencies.

Signed by former UN local weather chief Christiana Figueres and former UN Secretary-Normal Ban Ki Moon, the letter calls on nations to ascertain a “strict eligibility standards to exclude nations who don’t assist the section out/transition away from fossil power”. 

The letter doesn’t present particulars of who would decide this standards. Local weather House requested further info, however had not acquired a response on the time of publication.

Whereas the specialists recognise the significance of UN local weather talks, in addition they name for reform of the COP course of, writing that the “present construction merely can’t ship the change at exponential pace and scale” wanted to deal with the local weather disaster.

The COP29 presidency has been vocal about its disinterest in a fast fossil-fuel section out, with Azerbaijan’s President Ilham Aliyev even telling the opening plenary that fossil fuels are a “present from god” and that “we have to be lifelike” about power transition.

An evaluation of Aliyev’s speeches revealed at the moment by marketing campaign group 350.org discovered that the Azeri president defended or promoted fossil fuels in additional than three quarters of his power and climate-related speeches. In over a 12 months of such speeches, Aliyev by no means even talked about the Paris Settlement, the marketing campaign group discovered.

Some campaigners backed the reform proposal. Catherine Abreu, director of the Worldwide Local weather Politics Hub, stated it’s “demoralising” to listen to the messages despatched by Azerbaijan’s COP presidency.

She informed media in Baku that the UN local weather physique, UNFCCC, ought to give you a “battle of curiosity coverage” for delegates and the COP presidency that “places a firewall between fossil gas pursuits and the COP course of.

She additionally referred to as on nations to restrict the affect of fossil gas lobbyists at COP. In response to analysis revealed on Friday by the Kick Large Polluters Out coalition, nearly 1,800 lobbyists have proven up at COP29 – near 700 hundred lower than final 12 months however greater than the delegates of the ten most climate-vulnerable nations mixed. 

At the moment, nations can choose who participates of their delegations, both with a “occasion” or “occasion overflow” badge. They don’t select individuals with an “observer” badge. Most lobbyists are observers, however some nations resembling Japan, the UK, Canada and Italy introduced fossil gas lobbyists as a part of their nationwide delegations, the International Witness report discovered.

In response to the report, the most important group of fossil gas lobbyists is from an observer group referred to as the Worldwide Emissions Buying and selling Affiliation (IETA) which despatched 43 individuals.

However IETA denies this characterisation. Whereas it does have a consultant from French oil and fuel large TotalEnergies, an IETA spokesperson informed Local weather House their delegates have been “a broad combine” which “contains emitters who’re dedicated to a simply transition and answer suppliers who will assist them on that journey”. Drawing up an exclusion record shall be contentious.

Peace, Baku type 

It’s the “Power, Peace Aid and Restoration” Day right here in Baku. However in case you’re operating by the halls you gained’t word a lot change – as there hasn’t been in conflict-afflicted nations internationally, regardless of Azerbaijan’s COP Truce proposal. 

 The COP29 host needed to pause all of the conflicts on the earth – which quantity greater than 50 – throughout the local weather talks, impressed, they stated, by the Olympic Truce. 

On Friday, the COP Truce enchantment didn’t characteristic prominently on the agenda. Nonetheless, the presidency stated that the initiative acquired the assist of 132 nations. That features nations at present concerned in civil wars and worldwide conflicts, like Sudan, Myanmar, and the Democratic Republic of the Congo.

Azerbaijan itself has but to succeed in a fully-fledged peace take care of neighbouring Armenia. In response to Azeri media, Azerbaijan’s International Ministry stated that there can’t be any “bodily conferences” with their Armenian counterparts till December because the local weather summit is the federal government’s most important focus.

When the COP Truce was first introduced, local weather campaigners referred to as it a “performative… PR train” and “a distraction” from a separate UN-supported push to strengthen local weather motion in conflict-affected areas.

On that entrance, the COP29 presidency and 6 nations launched at the moment the ‘Baku Name on Local weather Motion for Peace, Aid, and Restoration’, aiming to develop a technique for stopping climate-induced wars and scaling up assist for conflict-struck weak nations.

The initiative will see the creation of a hub by which nations can “collaborate on peace and local weather initiatives”.

Throughout an occasion on this initiative, Local weather House requested Elshad Iskandarov, particular envoy of Azerbaijan’s Ministry of International Affairs, concerning the ceasefire enchantment. He stated that the truce was proposed to “foster peace on the earth and spotlight the significance of local weather” with out giving any additional particulars. 

However not everybody feels attuned to the “COP of peace” imaginative and prescient pushed by the COP presidency. Mohammed Usrof, founding father of the Palestinian Youth Local weather Negotiators Workforce, voiced considerations about COP29 being hosted in Azerbaijan as a result of the nation is Israel’s largest crude oil provider, as proven in a current report by Oil Change Worldwide.

Mila Sirychenko, a Ukrainian activist, had reservations about expressing her views at COP as a result of massive measurement of the Russian delegation. Russia’s occasion at this COP counts 900 individuals, solely topped by the Azeri (995) and  Brazil delegations (984). 

Chevron, ExxonMobil, BP, Shell and Eni – all corporations that offer crude oil to Israel – introduced a mixed complete of 39 lobbyists to the local weather summit.

“So many others proceed to be complicit with sustaining enterprise as ordinary,” Usrof informed Local weather House, referring to the virtually 1,800 fossil gas lobbyists at COP, lots of whom are a part of nations’ official delegations. “And, as we see, the enterprise as ordinary includes the genocide of Gazans.”

“Puzzling” lack of pledges for adaptation

There’s a “nice paradox” in proof at COP29 between leaders’ speeches urgently calling to maintain individuals secure from worsening local weather change impacts – and the obvious lack of cash accessible to try this, in accordance with the pinnacle of the Adaptation Fund.

The UN fund – which has been on the reducing fringe of efforts to construct resilience to excessive climate and rising seas for the final 15 years – solely managed to safe contributions of round $61 million from donor nations at a fundraising occasion on Thursday, towards its annual objective of $300 million.

This regardless of exhortations from UN Secretary-Normal Antonio Guterres and the UN local weather chief in the beginning of COP29 for wealthy nations to fill the enormous hole in adaptation funding, which might attain $187 billion-$359 billion a 12 months by 2030.

“These lacking {dollars} are usually not abstractions on a stability sheet: they’re lives taken, harvests misplaced, and improvement denied,” stated Guterres.

Whereas there’s nonetheless time for extra governments to return ahead with new pledges earlier than the tip of COP29, Adaptation Fund head Mikko Ollikainen informed Local weather House that “this 12 months the scenario appears to be like fairly troublesome”.    

“Contributor governments [are] nearly all speaking concerning the significance of adaptation – and fairly a number of of them are recognising the necessity for grant-based financing for adaptation particularly – so it’s puzzling how that pertains to the truth of there not being new pledges to the Adaptation Fund or adaptation funds basically,” he stated on the sidelines of the COP.

Eventually 12 months’s local weather convention in Dubai, the fund additionally fell wanting the identical goal – bringing in round $188 million. However there, rich governments had an excuse: they have been additionally requested to dig deep to get the fledgling loss and injury fund up and operating, which they did to the tune of practically $700 million.

This 12 months, nevertheless, they’ll’t disguise behind the loss and injury fund as new cash for that at COP29 has up to now amounted to little greater than Sweden’s $18.4 million pledge. Sweden has additionally stumped up round $763 million for the Inexperienced Local weather Fund and $12 million for the Adaptation Fund. 

This week total the Adaptation Fund has acquired pledges from 10 European nations and areas, with flood-hit Spain providing essentially the most ($19 million). The UK and the European Union are up to now no-shows, although Germany has stated it plans to contribute.

To make issues worse, the Least Developed International locations (LDC) Fund – additionally arrange below the UN local weather talks to assist weak nations adapt to local weather change – has needed to droop a deliberate pledging occasion at CO29 after it “didn’t get superb alerts” cash could be forthcoming, the chair of the LDC Group informed Local weather House on Friday.

Ollikainen stated “the route is kind of fallacious”, with wants going up and fewer cash coming into the coffers of his fund. The Adaptation Fund has a protracted pipeline of initiatives but when donors don’t cough up extra it can run out of cash, he added. It’s set to obtain earnings from a 5% levy on gross sales of offsets within the new UN carbon market, however that won’t begin till 2026, he famous.

Samoan minister Cedric Schuster, who chairs the Alliance of Small Island States (AOSIS), informed Local weather House he stays hopeful extra money will come by for weak nations at COP29 – and that the brand new local weather finance objective because of be agreed in Baku will guarantee contributions sooner or later.

“We will’t do something if there aren’t any pledges,” he stated.

Previous rifts again to hang-out carbon buying and selling talks

When a sequence of long-awaited guidelines for the UN carbon markets have been greenlit on COP’s opening day, informal observers of Article 6 negotiations might need surmised that talks over the remaining two weeks could be a breeze – in contrast to in earlier years.

It seems they have been very fallacious, as negotiators rapidly went again to their deeply-entrenched rifts. The principle battleground is Article 6.2, the part of the Paris Settlement that enables nations to commerce emission reductions or removals immediately by bilateral agreements.

Very similar to at COP28 final 12 months, there’s a break up between these pushing for extra transparency over how these exchanges happen and stronger oversight, and others wanting to maintain a extra laissez-faire, light-touch strategy.

The European Union is main the primary camp, with assist from the Alliance of Small Island States (AOSIS) and progressive Latin American nations within the AILAC group, whereas the US, Japan and the so-called Like-Minded Group of Creating International locations (LMDC) symbolize the latter place, two observers of the discussions informed Local weather House.

Is COP29 “breakthrough” on UN carbon market all it appears?

It has been a busy day and a half since a monster-sized textual content dropped early Thursday afternoon. Over 100 totally different choices featured over 43 pages. Negotiators struggled to have interaction with that, so the chair of the talks went again to the drafting board and supplied a extra streamlined 19 web page model on Friday morning.

Observers informed Local weather House that key provisions to make sure the integrity of the mechanism have disappeared from the draft choice. That features, for instance, necessities that will make the disclosure of sure details about the carbon-cutting actions obligatory slightly than voluntary. The EU is pushing for that to be added again in, Local weather House understands.

Injy Johnstone, a analysis affiliate in net-zero aligned offsetting at Oxford College, stated that “fault-lines over transparency, accessibility and environmental integrity stay, making the subsequent 24 hours essential for establishing widespread floor”.

As diplomats are nonetheless because of end a brand new spherical of negotiations late into the Baku Friday night time, the prospect of one other breakdown is beginning to daybreak on them.

In short…

New finance textual content – A brand new textual content on the post-2025 local weather finance objective (NCQG) was revealed at 6.30pm on Friday night. It’s been reduce from 33 to 25 pages – however doesn’t slim down the choices on essentially the most contentious points. Ministers shall be confronted subsequent week with robust choices on who pays and the way a lot.

Saturday’s march a no-go: The “Defund Genocide” march deliberate by civil society teams for Saturday has been cancelled, they are saying, with scaled-down choices nonetheless into consideration. “The venue can’t actually allow us to march,” stated Nicolas Haeringer from 350.org. There was a suggestion to march between the seats contained in the stadium, the place the talks are being held, which activists refused. One other campaigner claimed the true purpose is that “the presidency doesn’t need us to”. Complaints about how area for activists has been shrinking at current COPs have been widespread within the halls in Baku this previous week, backed up by a briefing from civil society networks.

Inexperienced mild for brand new forest carbon credit: A key watchdog for the carbon market has given its high-integrity seal of approval to a few methodologies for producing offsets that goal to scale back deforestation below so-called REDD+ initiatives. No credit have been issued up to now below the rulebooks for forest initiatives accredited by the Integrity Council for the Voluntary Carbon Market (ICVCM), however the physique stated “there’s a massive quantity of credit within the pipeline”. A whole lot of tens of millions of present REDD+ offsets have been issued below older methodologies however have confronted widespread criticism over their alleged lack of actual emissions reductions and failure to guard environmental and human rights. ICVCM didn’t assess the standards for these earlier initiatives and producers of these credit will be unable to say the high-integrity label until they swap to the brand new methodologies.

International locations decide to international power storage goal: International locations together with the UK, Uruguay, Belgium and Sweden have backed the COP presidency’s power storage pledge, which goals to extend international storage capability six occasions above 2022 ranges, reaching 1,500 gigawatts (GW) by 2030. To realize this, as an example, utility-scale battery storage alone, which was 54GW in 2023, would wish to extend 10 occasions by the tip of the last decade. “Storage should embrace assist for distributed in addition to utility-scale batteries, pumped-hydropower, and different longer length alternatives,” stated Jennifer Layke, international director of power on the World Assets Institute. ”One rising alternative for nations is to repurpose electrical automobile batteries for ‘second life’ functions.”

The article was amended to make clear the nations which have joined the COP29 power storage pledge.