Afrigather Advocacy group Tax Justice Community has ranked the British Virgin Islands, adopted by the Cayman Islands and Bermuda as “most complicit” in serving to companies underpay company revenue tax.
Traveler1116 | E+ | Getty Pictures
British abroad territories are the world’s prime enablers of company tax abuse, based on a rating by tax advocacy group Tax Justice Community.
The British Virgin Islands is the territory “most complicit” in serving to multinational companies underpay company revenue tax, adopted by the Cayman Islands and Bermuda, based on the newest replace to TJN’s Company Tax Haven Index earlier this month.
“The UK and its community of British tax havens, also known as the UK’s ‘second empire,’ are actually chargeable for a 3rd (33%) of all company tax abuse dangers measured by the index,” a spokesperson for TJN informed CNBC.
Switzerland ranked quantity 4, adopted by Singapore, Hong Kong and the Netherlands. Quantity eight on the listing is the self-governing dependency of the UK, Jersey, whereas the UK itself got here in at quantity 18.
TJN estimates that the UK and its British tax havens price different international locations an estimated $84 billion in company taxes yearly.
Defending themselves towards the costs made by the advocacy group, spokespersons from among the governments stated they had been in full compliance with worldwide tax requirements set by the Organisation for Financial Co-operation and Improvement.
The British authorities’s Overseas, Commonwealth and Improvement Workplace informed CNBC that the UK has been abiding by the Frequent Reporting Commonplace permitted by the OECD in 2014.
CRS is designed to extend transparency about tax issues on a worldwide scale and permit tax authorities to uncover revenue and property held abroad by their taxpayers.
FCDO informed CNBC it had greater than 100 international locations sharing CRS info with them, with over 9.2 million accounts reported in complete, as of the tip of 2022.
The company added that the Crown Dependencies and Abroad Territories had been separate jurisdictions with their very own democratically elected governments chargeable for their fiscal affairs.
A spokesperson for BVI Finance, which describes itself as “the voice of the British Virgin Islands’ monetary providers business,” informed CNBC that the territory adheres to international requirements, participates in international tax transparency initiatives below the OECD, and absolutely cooperates with the UK Authorities and legislation enforcement businesses in sharing “related” info.
Authorities tax departments of the Cayman Islands and Bermuda didn’t reply to CNBC inquiries.
Based mostly on the OECD requirements for figuring out and isolating international locations that allow multinational companies to abuse tax, the British Virgin Islands, the Cayman Islands and Bermuda, are presently rated as “not dangerous.”
TJN, which finds requirements such because the CRS as inadequate to cope with tax avoidance and fraud, has endorsed efforts by the United Nations to take over regulation of worldwide tax coverage.
In August, the UN unveiled a blueprint to develop a common tax accord for inclusive and efficient worldwide tax cooperation.
Broad commitments within the pointers embrace equitable taxation of multinational enterprises, addressing tax evasion and avoidance by high-net-worth people and efficient prevention and determination of tax disputes.
A complete of 110 UN Member States voted in favor of the phrases of reference for a brand new treaty, with 44 abstentions and solely eight nations voting towards it, together with the UK.
TJN has accused the UK of double requirements because the nation has strengthened its personal defenses towards international company tax avoidance previously few years, whereas voting towards the UN treaty.
Different nations that opposed the UN initiative had been the U.S., Australia, Canada, Israel, Japan, New Zealand and South Korea.
Based on the TJN, the world will seemingly lose $4.8 trillion to tax havens over the following 10 years if the OECD stays the world’s international tax regulator. The UN tax conference is the world’s finest shot to avert this loss, the TJN spokesperson stated.
The OECD is presently pushing its personal coverage geared toward higher addressing tax avoidance — a worldwide minimal tax deal that may impose a minimal efficient price of 15% on giant multinational companies.
TJN methodology — and pushback
To find out its rankings, TJN evaluated a rustic’s tax legal guidelines based mostly on 18 indicators, together with minimal company tax price, tax exemptions and the way aggressive a rustic’s tax treaties are towards different international locations.
That is the nation’s “Haven Rating,” and is supposed to judge how a lot “wiggle room” there may be for company tax abuse. The British Virgin Islands, Cayman Islands and Bermuda acquired the worst scores throughout all 18 indicators.
TJN then measured how a lot monetary exercise is carried out by multinational companies getting into and exiting the nation.
“This implies the index ranks company tax havens by how dangerous they’re to different international locations in observe, not simply in concept,” the TJN spokesperson stated.
The Company Tax Haven Index has been cited by the European Parliament and the European Fee, together with worldwide organizations such because the UN Human Rights Council and Oxfam.
Nonetheless, tax specialists equivalent to Niels Johannesen, director on the Oxford College Centre for Enterprise Taxation, disagree that the index is an correct measure for tax avoidance.
Johannesen informed CNBC that whereas TJN’s analysis is dependable for figuring out which international locations apply which authorized measures towards worldwide tax avoidance, he doubts the index is credible in measuring how a lot tax avoidance a jurisdiction facilitates.
“A extra significant metric is the place the shifted earnings of [multinational corporations] are booked. The most effective educational research with this focus level to Bermuda and the Caribbean jurisdictions as vital however estimate that Eire, as an example, receives extra shifted earnings than the three of them collectively,” he stated.
In the meantime, Leopoldo Parada, affiliate professor in tax legislation and co-director on the Centre for Enterprise Legislation and Apply on the College of Leeds, takes concern with the inclusion and framing of TJN’s haven rating indicators equivalent to lowest obtainable company revenue tax.
“All international locations are utilizing completely different instruments to compete to draw funding. Some have infrastructure, others higher tech or low cost labor … international locations which have much less aggressive benefits in a few of these areas have a tendency to supply different choices, together with very low company revenue tax charges and different points of the tax system,” Parada stated.
“It isn’t simply because a rustic has a really low company revenue tax price that we routinely ought to take into account {that a} nation is open for tax evasion … that nation is solely prepared to pay the commerce off.”
