The prosecution has poked holes in Ladislas Ntaganzwa’s appeal towards the life sentence handed to him by the Excessive Courtroom Chamber for Worldwide Crimes (HCCIC) in 2020 for his position within the 1994 Genocide towards the Tutsi.
The 60-year-old, a former Mayor (Bourgmestre) of Nyakizu Commune (now a part of Nyaruguru District) was found guilty of committing crimes together with genocide, in addition to rape and homicide as crimes towards humanity.
He was additionally accused of being on the helm of the April 15, 1994 assaults towards the Tutsi who had sought refuge at Cyahinda Catholic Parish in Nyakizu Commune, the place many lives perished.
Throughout the first occasion trial, witnesses pinned him on having gone to Butare and introduced with him the Gendermaine (Policemen) to Cyahinda, and ordered them to shoot the Tutsi civilians who have been gathered on the Catholic Parish.
The Gendermaine is alleged to have partnered with the Interahamwe and Burundian refugees within the killing.
After the HCCIC’s verdict towards him, Ntaganzwa filed an enchantment on the Courtroom of Enchantment in Kigali, which has been listening to his case since final week.
His enchantment plea is predicated on plenty of components, outstanding of which is the declare that the witness’ accounts that have been used towards him in the course of the first occasion trial weren’t reliable.
For instance, amongst different issues, he mentioned the witnesses who testified that they noticed him within the Cyahinda assaults contradicted one another regarding the kind of garments he was wearing, with some saying he was donned in a army shirt. In distinction, others mentioned he was dressed like a civilian.
Nonetheless, responding to his claims, Prosecutor Faustin Nkusi mentioned the way in which Ntaganzwa was dressed on that day was one thing very trivial that witnesses can overlook after twenty years.
Nonetheless, he famous that what issues is the truth that there may be sufficient proof that pins Ntaganzwa to having been on the scene, together with the truth that Ntaganzwa himself admitted that he was there.
Although Ntaganzwa admitted that he was on the scene along with the Gendermaine that he had introduced from Butare, he mentioned he was solely there to guard the residents.
He added that the capturing that occurred was solely unintentionally executed by one of many Gendermaine.
Nkusi challenged this, questioning how the mere unintended capturing might have led to the demise of the multitudes that perished on the scene.
“In addition to, it was not solely the Gendermaine who have been there in the course of the assault. The Interahamwe and Burundian refugees carrying conventional weapons have been there with them, aiding within the killing. Have been these additionally making an attempt to maintain the residents’ safety?” Nkusi requested.
A witness account cited by Nkusi acknowledged that Ntaganzwa instructed the Tutsi gathering on the Parish:
“You used your cash to purchase cows; we used ours to purchase weapons. Now stand tall and let the cow horns face off with the bullets.”
After that assertion, bullets have been heard throughout, and plenty of Tutsis have been slain by the Gendermaine, Interahamwe, and Burundian refugees.
Nkusi additionally instructed the judges that after the assaults, Ntaganzwa wrote a report and despatched it to his prime leaders, informing them that that they had fought with the “Inkotanyi” in Cyahinda and overwhelmed them.
“If the capturing was merely unintended capturing as he claims, why did it end in killing younger youngsters, outdated males, ladies?” the prosecutor requested.
Ntaganzwa was arrested in 2015 within the Democratic Republic of Congo and extradited to Rwanda in 2016.
He was one of many 9 folks indicted by the Worldwide Prison Tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR) however had not but been arrested by the point the UN courtroom closed store in 2015.
Join free AllAfrica Newsletters
Get the newest in African information delivered straight to your inbox
In 2012, the ICTR, as a part of its completion technique, determined to confer with Rwandan prosecution the case information of six of the 9 main suspects who had remained at massive.
These included Ladislas Ntaganzwa, Fulgence Kayishema, Charles Sikubwayo, Aloys Ndimbati, Ryandikayo, and Phineas Munyarugarama.
The opposite three: Felicien Kabuga, Augustin Bizimana, and Protais Mpiranya could be tried by the Worldwide Residual Mechanism for Prison Tribunals (IRMCT).
Kabuga was arrested in France in 2020 and is at present being tried by IRMCT on counts together with genocide, complicity in genocide, direct and public incitement to commit genocide, try to commit genocide, conspiracy to commit genocide, and persecution and extermination – each as crimes towards humanity.
For Bizimana, it came to be confirmed that he died in 2000, and comparable information was confirmed for Protais Mpiranya, whom the ICTR confirmed to have died on October 5, 2006, in Harare, Zimbabwe.